Grilled cheese and tomato soup is warm comfort food, and a mainstay during the cold snow laden winter that I hope we are finally coming out of around these parts. As a child this would frequently be on the lunch menu, and was one of the first meals my siblings and I learned to make for ourselves as we grew.
My mother would frequently make our toast in the oven instead of the toaster, and I’m not sure why, unless it was because she was saving time and could make more slices at one time, but whatever the reason, I still like my toast made in the oven. It seems to be a little chewier and sweeter, and I like how the butter sinks into the bread! All this to say, when I saw the idea for making grilled cheese sandwiches in the oven, I thought it was absolutely genius, and had to try it right away! I’ve since tried it several different ways, and it is AWESOME! The cheese melts better inside, and I can make six at a time easily on my baking sheet, and the sandwiches get slightly chewy and seem sweeter! Once you try it, I don’t think you’ll ever go back to making them in a frying pan!
These are ridiculously easy to make: Start with your favorite bread and cheese and some butter.
My favorite bread that I’ve tried so far with these sandwiches is the Schwebel’s Sweet Wheat, (although I’ve made them with whole grain bread and Italian as well, and they’re all good), and since I’ve never cared a lot for the taste of processed cheese slices, I like to use a good quality cheddar cheese slice. Ham or sliced turkey is optional and delicious, but my favorite is simply with the gooey cheese alone.
For your convenience this post contains some affiliate links. Click here to read my full disclosure policy.
Depending on how many sandwiches you’re making, you need 2 slices of bread for each, and about a Tablespoon of butter for each sandwich, and of course at least one cheese slice for each. Now I like to melt my butter a bit and brush it on the outside of each slice, but it’s probably not necessary, if you prefer instead to use a knife and spread un-melted butter on your bread. Lay them out on your baking sheet.
After buttering, adding the cheese, and topping with more buttered bread, they are ready to go in the oven.
In a preheated 425 degree oven, bake on one side for around 6 minutes, checking though to get it to your preferred degree of “toastyness.” Then carefully flip over and bake for another 3 minutes or so, again watching for the perfect “brown-ness” for your taste.
These are truly amazingly scrumptious!
- Favorite bread
- Favorite cheese
- 1 Tablespoon butter for each sandwich (melted optional)
- Turkey or ham (optional)
- I like to melt my butter a bit and brush it on the outside of each slice, but it's probably not necessary, if you prefer to use a knife and spread unmelted butter on your bread.
- After buttering, adding the cheese, and topping with more buttered bread, they are ready to go in the oven.
- In a preheated 425 degree oven, bake on one side for around 6 minutes, checking though to get it to your preferred degree of "toastyness." Then carefully flip over and bake for another 3 minutes or so, again watching for the perfect "browness" for your taste.
The cheese gets hot and bubbly throughout, and the bread becomes slightly chewy and somehow a bit sweeter.
Who knew that making grilled cheese in the oven would be not only more efficient, but also much tastier!
This is a great way to make grilled cheese for a crowd too!
I’ve also made these with turkey and ham slices, and they are a delicious alternative!
If you like grilled cheese, these Grilled Cheese with Tomato and Pesto are amazing too!
Hope you enjoy!
Idea from Lynn’s Kitchen Adventures
Bonnie Morgan says
Glad you shared this. Just made some for the grandchildren today and the oven method would be easier and make more at the same time. Thanks for all the details all worked out. Pinned for next time.
Margo says
You’ll never go back to the old way, they’re so easy and yummy!
Kelli B says
These looks delicious! Thanks for sharing!
Margo says
Hope you’ll try it, they’re so good made in the oven!
Cheryl says
I stopped by from Saturday Night Fever to check out your post because Grilled Cheese in the Oven seemed like a great idea and looks so yummy! What a great idea to get them all done at one time! I would like to invite you to share your talents on my new link party The Yuck Stops Here on Hot Momma’s Kitchen Chaos at http://mommasangelbaby.com. I hope to see you there! HUGS
Thea says
I love grill cheese sandwiches! I also love this new way for me to prepare them. Thank you!
Margo says
Can’t wait for you to try them this way, they’re so good!
Kim of Mo'Betta says
Oh my…it’s lunch time and now I want grilled cheese!
Margo says
This is a great way to make it! 🙂
Miz Helen says
Hi Margo,
I love oven toast but have never tried a grilled cheese in the oven, this looks awesome! Thank you so much for sharing with Full Plate Thursday and have a very special week.
Come Back Soon!
Miz Helen
Andi @ The Weary Chef says
I love making grilled cheese in the oven too! It’s probably user error, but I usually end up burning the bread before the cheese melts when I make grilled cheese in a skillet. I often don’t even butter the bread, so that makes it a healthier way to go too. Your sandwich combos look delicious. Thanks so much for sharing your ideas with us at Saturday Night Fever!
Kristin Dunn says
Your pictures made me hungry! I love grilled cheese in the oven! Pinned and followed you on FB and Pinterest. Visiting from Modest Mondays.
Mandie Brice says
These look so delicious! I totally agree – no processed slices!
Julie @ Back To My Southern Roots says
I made some grilled cheese yesterday in the skillet. I never thought about putting it in the oven. I will try that next time. Sounds like a great idea!
Miz Helen says
Hope you are having a great day and thanks so much for sharing your awesome post with us at Full Plate Thursday.
Come Back Soon
Miz Helen
helenfern says
Looks fantastic – Thanks for sharing at the What’s for Dinner Party!
Cindy's FTD Journey (@monkeyami) says
You have got me wanting a grilled cheese sandwich now! I haven’t ever had a grilled cheese sandwich out of the oven before. I love that you can make a bunch at a time this way!
Margo says
I love how convenient it is!
Jhuls says
I have to try making grilled cheese in the oven. Must be easier than making them on the stove top. Thanks for sharing at Fiesta Friday party!
FrugalHausfrau says
Great idea! Happy FF!
Mollie
Theresa says
I have never made grilled cheese in the oven. I have to try. This is great for making everyones at once too. Thanks for sharing at the Inspiration Spotlight party. PInned & sharing. See you again soon.